The difference between useful and useless feedback is specificity. Ask concrete questions that force concrete answers, not vague prompts that get vague responses.
Most managers ask their employees for feedback like it's a box to check. They run annual surveys, collect vague answers, and file them away. The trick is asking specific questions that force concrete answers. Not "How can I improve?" but "Are there any blockers you're experiencing that I can help with?" Not "Do you feel supported?" but "What could I do to help you work more productively?" The difference between useful and useless feedback is specificity.
The questions that matter most cut against what managers want to hear. "What is something I do that you find limiting or frustrating?" makes people uncomfortable. So does "If you were in my shoes, what would you change?" But these questions surface your blind spots. Your team may look like a well-oiled machine from the management level, but some individuals will beg to differ. Each employee has at one point thought to themselves, "If I were in charge, I would do this and it would make everyone's job easier." Ask the question and get exposed to reality.
The tactical questions reveal process problems. "Are there any workplace processes that you feel are not helping you?" will surface the pesky, time-consuming processes that management values as part of company culture but the rest of the company secretly views as a burden. Maybe they're tired of spending time on repetitive online training modules. Maybe the new software is actually slowing processes down. You may not have the power to resolve every headache, but you should take the time to listen.
The pattern here is simple: make feedback surveys actually useful by keeping them anonymous, asking specific questions instead of vague ones, and following up with action. Track trends over time to identify systemic issues rather than one-off complaints. Close the loop by discussing changes based on employee input. This builds trust and engagement. Don't just collect feedback and move on. Share key takeaways, explain what actions are being taken, and solicit additional thoughts. Show that the feedback loop is active, not performative.
Check out the full stdlib collection for more frameworks, templates, and guides to accelerate your technical leadership journey.